In order to illustrate my brilliant insight, I must first confess to downloading a game of Klondike Solitaire, my preferred time-waster that had to be replaced after my recent computer crash. I’ve been playing it on and off now for close to a month, and I find it so irritating I might have to give it up.
My irritation is that whenever I win a game, the screen shouts “Congratulations! You won!”
Fine. But when I lose, the screen says “You have run out of moves. Good Game!”
And that’s what I find so irritating. It reminds me of an enabling teacher or parent who tries to build self-confidence in their child or student by praising them even when they fail.
That is not how mature self-confidence is built.
Because self-confidence doesn’t come from others’ opinions of our accomplishments. It doesn’t even come from always succeeding. It comes from confidence in our own ability to assess what we have done. We need to be able to say “Yes, I did my best,” or “I did as well as I wanted to,” or “I didn’t get this right; can I do it better? Do I want to do better? If so, how?” At that point, we might ask for advice. But that is quite different from encouragement based on false praise.
Yes, we need to know that we are loved. That is not the same thing as needing indiscriminate praise. We need to learn to be proud – or not – of ourselves. What parents and teachers need to help children do is to evaluate themselves. “What do you think about that work you just did?” is potentially a more helpful response than offering our own assessments as if our opinions were what really matter.
If we can’t judge our own accomplishments (or failures), we remain dependent psychologically. We can’t stand on our own two feet. And as human beings, we need to be able to stand up for what we believe in, for what we decide is important, even when it seems that everybody else disagrees with us. We decide, for instance, that we have to be thinner, more beautiful, smarter, richer, more popular, more famous because that’s what everybody says.
But it’s not the recipe for happiness.
So was this a good post? can I play another game of Solitaire now?