I am feeling today rather like a woman who after 50 years of marriage, has just discovered that her husband has never been faithful to her. She might have known that he was a womanizer, even occasionally had a one-night stand or passing affair. But now she finds out that he has a family in three different ports. Or is wanted for extortion and murder or war crimes in another country.
I have just read as much of the report on the CIA torture of terrorist suspects as I can bear. And I am almost vomiting.
My America! have you ever been what I thought you were? The very foundations of this country began with the ethnic cleansing of 80-90% of the American Indians who had been here for hundreds of years. Today, the treaty violations continue. How many of us have ever equated this with the ethnic cleansing in other places in the world which we hold in such abhorrence? Or ever thought that perhaps, we like other countries, have re-written our history to eliminate this shameful guilt?
And then there were the African slaves, brought in like cattle on the ships. They might have been technically freed by Abraham Lincoln’s proclamation, but even the Christian churches continued to assure the white man that they were inferior to us white folk. So they still could not drink at the same water fountains, use the same rest rooms, sit in the front of the bus, eat in “white” restaurants or stay in the same hotels.
Two days ago I listened to a newscast and read a report which has just been published that shocked me to the core. The ghettos in which, even today, Blacks are crowded, is a result of federal law requiring that housing be segregated. Ghettos then were not and are not today the result of White prejudice or of Black poverty. Initially, it was the law of the country that appropriated land for Whites Only which was highly preferable. It was not zoned, as Black residential areas were, for polluting factories and where houses of prostitution were tolerated. Nor were mortgages granted to Blacks by the banks. This law was not found to be unconstitutional by the Supreme Court until 1955. By that time, Whites had amassed significant wealth in the real estate they owned. That pattern has continued, and today, the great difference between average Black & White wealth in America is a result of the value of the homes they own. Generations of Blacks have been disenfranchised because of these discriminatory laws. I think we need a new kind of affirmative action to right this injustice.
And now we have George W Bush, a former president of these United States, and Dick Cheney, his defense secretary, saying that the CIA torture of terrorist suspects was justified and that those torturers are true patriots. What Cheney objects to is the publication of the reports. “The transparency and honesty found in this report represent a gross violation of our nation’s values,” he says. “As long as I have air to breathe, I will do everything in my power to wipe out the scourge of torture reports from the face of the Earth.” As far as I have seen, he has not objected to the torture. It’s that it is being published. The sheer hypocrisy of it.
I know that we are a country that loves guns. I know we are a country that thinks we are the best because we have the biggest bombs. I knew we went to war in Iraq over oil, not over the weapons of mass destruction that some politicians knew were not there even before the war began.
But I didn’t realize how often and deeply we really really don’t mean what we say. Do we really believe in the rule of law? Are we really committed to freedom for all?
Oh America, my America. Who are we after all? Are we going to say NO! WE WON’T HAVE IT? When we reach the tipping point, which way will we tip in the end?
PS: I have just read a blog post covering the Rothstein’s research on the disenfranchisement of Blacks from the property market from which so many of us middle class whites have profited so richly. The author, like me, didn’t know it was happening, but on looking back, now sees events in quite a different perspective. It’s an easy read – and worth it. Hands up! Why We All Can’t Breathe